Click to read the article
Savage Grace (2008)
Genre: Dramas
Starring: Julianne Moore, Stephen Dillane, Eddie Redmayne, Elena Anaya, Unax Ugalde
Screenwriter: Howard A. Rodman
Producer: Iker Monfort, Katie Rournel, Pamela Koffler, Christine Vachon
Composer: Fernando Velazquez
Reviews
This film has plenty of strong performances and provocative themes, but is too episodic to come together.
Kalin is a very brave and honest filmmaker (and plenty astute), but his subject matter argues that some stories need not be told.
So muddled and self-important that none of its characters, not even with Moore's ferocious performance, can take shape.
Blessed with a fine script, solid cast, smashing production design, and a message that drives home the notion that money isn't everything.
Rather than imitate the postmodernism chic of Far from Heaven or the parodic silliness of Die, Mommie, Die!, Kalin settles for a nondescript style whose sole function is to stay out of Moore's way.
The lurid plot, based on a very true story, isn't the problem here...stilted dialogue), and not nearly enough coaxing Moore out of her habit of clenching her face at the camera.
Dark humor, along the lines of "The Honeymoon Killers," gives way to fractured set pieces that gesture toward the film's gratuitous climax, one that's destined to bestow upon it a cult status.
When [Moore] embarrasses her son by forcing him to read a passage from de Sade's Justine (introduction by Georges Bataille!), ... it's a potent familial cruelty to place alongside the best of Davis and Crawford.
It is very pretty, and it feigns elegance well, but it is tawdry and shallow.
The meandering story of a wealthy, worthless family of society humping layabouts.
Sadly, it's a classic example of why some novels just don't translate well when adapted to the screen.
Given that the story concerns murder, incest and insanity, Kalin deserves credit for refusing to sensationalize the text or even draw on the melodrama but the film is too episodic and fractured, lacking the conviction and style of his first film, Swoon.
By scrupulously avoiding melodrama, [director] Kalin ensures that the characters remain recognizably human despite their flaws and monstrous weaknesses.
A crushingly unsuccessful glimpse into the lives of the rich, peripatetic heirs of the Bakelite plastics fortune.


Top Critic