Click to read the article
Comment
09/29/07
Silk (2007)
7
%
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work 
Reviews Counted:55
Fresh:4
Rotten:51
Average Rating:3.8/10
Consensus: Silk contains a simple love triangle story but director Francois Gerard goes to painstaking lengths to turn it into a protracted and wearisome art film.
Theatrical Release:09-11-2007
Synopsis: With SILK, director François Gerard (THIRTY TWO SHORT FILMS ABOUT GLENN GOULD, THE RED VIOLIN) brings Alessandro Baricco's bestselling novel to sumptuous life. Michael Pitt stars as Herve Joncour,... [More]
Starring: Michael Pitt, Keira Knightley, Koji Yakusho, Alfred Molina
Director: Francois Gerard
Reviews for Silk
THE new Keira Knightley film is a visual delight. Unfortunately, the dialogue is far from delightful.
11/09/07
A flat story, lean characters and a miscast lead make this a poor facsimile of period epics like Farewell My Concubine.
11/23/07
Top CriticTremulous eroticism a-go-go, but it's all completely lifeless.
11/09/07
A problematic period movie, Silk is anything but finely spun. Unaided by lacklusture performances from the leads, director Francois Girard seems more interested in crafting a beautiful travelogue than he does a moving melodrama.
11/09/07
Top CriticSluggish storytelling enlivens neither Pitt’s infatuation with a local concubine nor the stubbornly feudal society it’s set against. Worst of all, though, you just never give a toss.
11/09/07
Gorgeous to look at but ultimately disappointing, Silk is let down by stilted direction, an extremely dull script and a badly miscast Michael Pitt.
11/08/07
Francois Girard's film proves a cross-cultural yawn, as if taking its cue from Pitt's blank-faced blandness and Keira Knightley's anaemic support.
11/09/07
Top CriticDralon is more like it.
11/09/07
Top CriticCrashing bore of a movie.
11/09/07
Top CriticThe stilted dialogue makes all of the actors sound as if they're being dubbed into English, badly, especially the English-speaking ones (Alfred Molina, looking seriously bored).
09/13/07
a singularly uninvolving bit of piffle crafted as though those who made it were afraid of waking someone
09/12/07
The movie looks gorgeous ... but the story never really builds momentum; you keep waiting for the 'real' action to start, but it never does.
09/14/07
The movie is at its best as a collage of environments representing states of mind.
10/17/07
Failing to make a lick of rational sense, Silk grasps at poetic straws.
09/14/07
It is worse than a straightforward bad film, it is a middling, stagnant film that could have been extraordinary.
02/28/08
It is interesting and not riveting, lovely and not luxurious, good and not great. Some may even find it boring. It certainly is repetitive.
09/28/07
Although the period-piece film has all the trappings, from beautiful people to an obligatory sense of tragedy, it never follows through. In fact, its love story needs a shove -- it just lies there.
09/14/07
Here's a little game you can play if you get bored during Silk, and you will get bored during Silk: How many actors do you suppose were offered the lead role before the producers settled on Michael Pitt?
09/13/07
A film that manages to remove just about everything that makes soap operas entertaining.
09/14/07
Latest News for Silk
September 11, 2007:
Silk preview & trailer 
More...
August 23, 2007:
It's hard to imagine Brit beauty Knightley playing the long-suffering wife of an adulterous spouse who'd look at another woman - even if he's got a thing for a seductive geisha in faraway Japan, who happens to be the personal property of a powerful baron.
More...
August 22, 2007:
Trailer & Poster review
More...
What’s Hot On RT
Other News
Fresh Links
Featured
RT on YouTube
Subscribe to RT's YouTube channel and don't miss a second of our cracking video content.
RT on Twitter
Follow Rotten Tomatoes and join us as we tweet about the week's releases.
IGN RSS Feeds