Article Ratings & Comments

|
jonboy83 writes: on Aug 28 2008 10:13 PM This guy also didn't like The Big Lebowski, so I'm definitely taking this with a huge freaking grain of salt... He doesn't seem to appreciate the Coen's brand of humor, which I can't get enough of. Can't wait to see this movie... (Reply to this) |
|
Some guy you dont know writes: on Aug 29 2008 12:55 PM ZOMG DIE U (Reply to this) |
|
Some guy you dont know writes: on Aug 29 2008 12:57 PM ZOMG DIE U (Reply to this) |
|
Bedram B. writes: on Aug 29 2008 04:57 PM Is it just me, or does this guy give a lot of good films bad reviews? He's way too harsh of a critic. Too much of an ego probably. (Reply to this) |
|
Some guy you dont know writes: on Aug 29 2008 08:54 PM ZOMG DIE !!! !! !!!! ! !!! !! !!!! ! !!! (Reply to this) |
|
filmdick writes: on Aug 30 2008 09:04 AM suck a dick todd (Reply to this) |
|
w@velength writes: on Aug 31 2008 01:41 AM Shutup Bruce. (Reply to this) |
|
HumanSlaughterhouse writes: on Aug 31 2008 09:58 PM Oh no! Someone didn't like a film by the Coen brothers! It's such a tragedy! I should probably write something hateful here because I can't stand it when other people have a different opinion than I do! (Reply to this) |
|
escobrown writes: on Sep 01 2008 10:04 AM i'm not so sure the expectations of an "objective" critic should ultimately have an impact on their review. the film should be judged in and of itself, no? (Reply to this) |
|
savethemooses writes: on Sep 01 2008 02:15 PM FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL FAIL. FAIL. (Reply to this) |
|
prevalentmind writes: on Sep 03 2008 07:19 AM In my opinion if you're a critic you should be able to take it as much as you can dish it- so iwht that in mind: Todd not only are you so out of touch with the generation your IN let alone the ones that followed you are absolutely THE most boring critic ever on the job today. I simply see your name and I want to lose myself in paint drying on a wall because I know it'll be more interesting than the constant egotistic yabbering you do about the films you view. Whether you liked the movie or not isn't the case. You're bland, you're boring, and discussing film with you would probably be the worst most frustrating film experience in the known world. Keep pretending as if your job matters. Useless profession. (Reply to this) |
|
prevalentmind writes: on Sep 03 2008 07:27 AM Sorry for not proof reading but christ is he ever a tool- "Every second word in this review has been pulled out of a grotesquely overused thesaurus, exaggerating single words to such an extent that you are no longer able to deduce which is rant and which is critique and which is McCarthy's self serving quest to use every word known to man whether man uses those words or not...A review that seem misjudged from it's opening words and thereafter deserves such treatment rightfully so." (Reply to this) |
|
Some guy you dont know writes: on Sep 03 2008 01:27 PM In reply to this comment (#2010499) U (Reply to this) |
|
canidrinkit writes: on Sep 04 2008 10:11 AM In reply to this comment (#2015677) (Reply to this) |
|
faisy_master writes: on Sep 04 2008 11:04 AM I always take this todddy **** words opposite ! ... He says the movie suck, it must be a classic ! (Reply to this) |
|
WesM writes: on Sep 06 2008 07:59 AM In reply to this comment (#2015323) So film criticism is an utterly useless and pointless profession? From the guy with an account registered on a website that revolves around film criticism? In fairness, it's true, his complaint seems aimed at common traits of Coen brothers films; but hey, if he doesn't like how the Coens direct, there's nothing wrong with him voicing his complaint on a movie-by-movie basis. I don't hear anyone complaining about this type of criticism when it's of directors they don't like. Perhaps we should (not just here, in general) stop accusing critics of being "biased", and take a look at our own blinding fanboyish bias first. (Reply to this) |
|
thisHATEinside writes: on Sep 06 2008 11:35 AM Hmmm ... I've realized that I can't stand anyone with the last name "McCarthy", especially this one and Joe, both of whom are so far up their asses they don't know what they're talking about. Of course, since this guy hates just about every great mainstream film, I'm going to take this as a positive review! :D (Reply to this) |
|
Some guy you dont know writes: on Sep 06 2008 12:45 PM In reply to this comment (#2019958) You almost had me there... But then you used 'fanboy' and lost all my respect... But atleast you almost made a point there, maybe next time. (Reply to this) |
|
WesM writes: on Sep 06 2008 07:40 PM In reply to this comment (#2020249) lol, ah well. (Reply to this) |
|
WesM writes: on Sep 06 2008 07:48 PM Also, just for the record, I think this looks (and hope it will be) really good, and I've loved just about every Coen brother film besides Barton Fink. (Reply to this) |









