Click to read the article
The Claim (2001)
Runtime: 2 hrs 1 min
Synopsis: In transporting Thomas Hardy's THE MAYOR OF CASTERBRIDGE to the American West, English director Michael Winterbottom has fashioned an audacious, epic anti-Western that is a haunting achievement. Set in 1849, the story concerns Mr. Dillon (Peter Mullan), the ruler of Kingdom Come, a... In transporting Thomas Hardy's THE MAYOR OF CASTERBRIDGE to the American West, English director Michael Winterbottom has fashioned an audacious, epic anti-Western that is a haunting achievement. Set in 1849, the story concerns Mr. Dillon (Peter Mullan), the ruler of Kingdom Come, a snow-covered mining town in Northern California. The story opens with the arrival of Dalglish (Wes Bentley), a handsome surveyor for the Pacific Coast Railroad, who is searching for the most sensible way to turn the dream of a transcontinental railroad into a reality. Also drifting into town are the seriously ill Elena (Nastassja Kinski) and her daughter, Hope (Sarah Polley), who have ambiguous ties to Dillon. Immediately, Hope and Dalglish become acquainted, but their potential romance is threatened by the presence of Lucia (Milla Jovavich), a Portuguese madam who lives with Dillon. As Dalglish reaches a decision regarding the railroad, Dillon must painfully confront mistakes he's made in the past, triggering a series of tragic occurrences. Winterbottom's lush, expansive film miraculously manages to retain the somber spirit of Hardy's classically English tale. Employing the techniques that made Robert Altman's MCCABE & MRS. MILLER such a breathtaking spectacle--including Alwin Kuchler's dazzling cinematography and Michael Nyman's mesmerizing score--Winterbottom proves once again that he is an accomplished filmmaker who isn't afraid to tackle any genre. [More]
Genre: Dramas
Starring: Peter Mullan, Sarah Polley, Milla Jovovich, Wes Bentley, Nastassja Kinski
Reviews
[Winterbottom] fails to infuse the small moments of people's lives with emotion of any kind.
In all other respects, this is fine, fine filmmaking, it's just hard to feel very involved.
If the story was as crisp as the snow, and the plot advanced faster than a glacier, this might have been a better film.
Broody and beautiful, The Claim is guaranteed to give you the chills.
The Claim works best as an antitraditional Western epic that presents an allegorical drama of fate, retribution and redemption.
The audience is simply left with the task of fitting together the allegory's easy pieces.
At the center are the impeccable performances of all five leads.
Watching The Claim is like re-visiting a collegiate literature class in Thomas Hardy.
Related Forums
by: Leslie Brudne 4/18/01


Top Critic