Click to read the article
The Dying Gaul (2005)
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work ![]()
Reviews Counted:66
Fresh:32
Rotten:34
Average Rating:5.7/10
Consensus: Though it has a fine cast, The Dying Gaul's plot feels calculated and too intellectualized.
Runtime: 1 hr 45 mins
Genre: Dramas
Synopsis: Playwright/screenwriter Craig Lucas (The Secret Lives of Dentists, Longtime Companion, Prelude to a Kiss) makes an audacious directorial debut with The Dying Gaul, a fiercely original psychological... Playwright/screenwriter Craig Lucas (The Secret Lives of Dentists, Longtime Companion, Prelude to a Kiss) makes an audacious directorial debut with The Dying Gaul, a fiercely original psychological thriller based on his play of the same name. Part Sunset Boulevard, part Greek tragedy, The Dying Gaul is a tale of lust, power, corruption, betrayal and revenge set in the seductive world of the Hollywood elite. Peter Sarsgaard stars as Robert Sandrich, a fledgling screenwriter who has been living on the fringes, writing spec script after spec script to no avail. His life changes when he is offered a million dollars for his latest and most personal work - "The Dying Gaul," the raw, autobiographical story of the death of his lover. But there's a catch - the studio thinks the project will be much more commercially viable if Robert will only change the dead lover to a woman. Making the offer is Jeffrey (Campbell Scott), a smooth, ruthless and sexually avaricious studio executive who seduces Robert with the intoxicating Hollywood cocktail of power, money and sex. Patricia Clarkson stars as Jeffrey's wife, Elaine, a former screenwriter now ensconced in a Malibu villa with children, a housekeeper, and time on her hands. She brings the grieving Robert into the family fold, drawn by his talent and his pain. When Robert confides that he finds solace, both sexual and emotional, in the ghost-like world of chat rooms, the curious Elaine meets him there anonymously. As their online dialogue unfolds, she discovers that Robert and her husband are having an affair. The shock of that revelation - and the unexpected way she responds - sets off a dangerous series of deceptions, confessions and betrayals. Never sliding into the conventional histrionics of the thriller, The Dying Gaul is infinitely more complex, as the lines between predator and prey, sadist and victim shift and blur. Visually stunning, The Dying Gaul contrasts the dazzling California sunlight that bleaches out the palm-lined movie studios and oceanfront estates with the cold and detached world of cell phones and computers. What emerges is a truly original postmodern Hollywood noir, unsettling, unpredictable and morally explosive. As John Cooper writes in the 2005 Sundance Film Festival program, "Lucas has honed a precise, interlocking plot that exploits his scalpel-sharp irony. The Dying Gaul will push you to the edge of your seat, simultaneously unnerving you with its complexity and frightening you with its believability." --© Hole Digger Studios [More]
Starring: Patricia Clarkson, Campbell Scott, Peter Sarsgaard, Robin Bartlett
Starring: Patricia Clarkson, Campbell Scott, Peter Sarsgaard, Robin Bartlett, Bill Camp, Thomas Jay Ryan
Director: Craig Lucas
Director: Craig Lucas
Screenwriter: Craig Lucas
Producer: Campbell Scott, George Van Buskirk
Composer: Steve Reich
Studio: Strand Releasing
Reviews for The Dying Gaul
Given the ominous title of both the film and the screenplay-within-the-film, chances seem good that someone will die.
Like minimalist composer Steve Reich's prickly, tense music on the soundtrack, the movie itself is too often too intellectual, experimental and abstract.
By the end of the film, relationships have turned so corrosive that the characters leave an ugly aftertaste in the mind of the viewer.
The movie doesn't completely please, but more disappointing is that it no longer aims to appall, either.
Lucas' use of chat rooms as a plot-moving device is pretty hackneyed, and when the story takes a thriller-like turn in the third act, it feels really forced.
There is some ambiguity about why a final event takes place, and that's all right, but the way in which the movie reveals it is, I think, singularly ineffective.
The onscreen results wobble a bit in the climactic, murderous narrative turns. Yet en route it works on its own terms, and in what is essentially a three-person picture, Lucas has cast the leads with the right three people.
Verbally well-matched, morally ambiguously fascinating together, they are exciting to watch.* All three leads give extraordinary performances.
Quickly goes downhill, changing into something so dull that even its illustrious cast can't save it.
Stagey, but an original story about a producer and a screenwriter whose relationship is not entirely professional.
The film plays for keeps: It hurts and it doesn't back away from messy questions about art, commerce and conscience.
The Dying Gaul begins with a Herman Melville quote: 'Woe to him who seeks to please rather than appall.' Let them serve not as words of wisdom, but of warning.
The movie always feels as if it's on the verge of a major discovery. It ends without convincing us that any such discovery has been made.
It's his heavy-handed and often ludicrous plotting that is the film's downfall.
More DVDs
| Tomatometer Percentage | Movie |
|---|---|
| 36% 36% | Angels & Demons |
| 25% 25% | Four Christmases |
| 68% 68% | Funny People |
| 95% 95% | Star Trek |
| 14% 14% | The Ugly Truth |
| Tomatometer Percentage | Movie |
|---|---|
| 83% 83% | Harry Potter and the H… |
| 67% 67% | Public Enemies |
| 75% 75% | Julie & Julia |
| 95% 95% | The Cove |
| 85% 85% | World's Greatest Dad |
What’s Hot On RT
Other News
Sponsored Links
Around The Network
- The Dying Gaul at Rotten Tomatoes
- The Dying Gaul at IGN
- The Dying Gaul at AskMen
Fresh Links
Featured

Subscribe to RT's YouTube channel and don't miss a second of our cracking video content.

Follow Rotten Tomatoes and join us as we tweet about the week's releases.



Top Critic

