It is so busy with its crosscut structure and its interlocking stories that it never really gives us anyone to identify with.
Comment
04/27/01
One Night at McCool's (2001)
33
%
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work 
Reviews Counted:102
Fresh:34
Rotten:68
Average Rating:4.7/10
Consensus: Critics say this blend of film noir and screwball comedy seems to think itself more clever and hip than it actually is. Also, the crucial femme fatale role needs a better, more mature actress than Tyler.
Runtime: 1 hr 40 mins
Genre: Comedies
Synopsis: The title refers to the night when three men, Randy (Matt Dillon), his cousin Carl (Paul Reiser) and Detective Dehling (John Goodman), all meet Jewel Valentine (Liv Tyler) at a bar called McCool's.... [More]
Starring: Michael Douglas, Matt Dillon, John Goodman, Paul Reiser
Director: Harald Zwart
Reviews for One Night at McCool's
Top CriticThe jokes are only funny sometimes, the stunt casting feels gratuitous after a while, and a barrage of bullets at the end is out of place.
04/27/01
They should've done less howling and more character development and plotting.
04/27/01
Tyler's tongue-in-cheek noir goddess transcends cliche and the screenplay's other shortcomings terrifically.
04/27/01
Tyler simply doesn't have the acting chops to pull it off.
04/27/01
The movie is certainly amusing, but it's uneven.
04/27/01
The main actress isn't very talented.
04/27/01
A full-on, mean-spirited bore that's neither as sexy nor as smart as it thinks it is.
04/27/01
Even when the film makes no sense, it's still an enjoyably off-beat exercise.
04/27/01
Specific bits of humor sometimes seem forced, and the film never balances its array of sex, laughs and violence.
04/27/01
The screenplay ... is never clever enough or challenging enough to really exploit a terrific premise.
04/27/01
It's hard not to get cheesed off by the fear-of-sex, fear-of-women theme operating here.
04/27/01
An offbeat, dark comedy filled with plenty of sight gags that work.
04/27/01
Top CriticThe bulk of the humor is, like Andrew Dice Clay with black rimmed glasses, dweeby and cheap.
04/27/01
A picture whose wildly different components never really coalesce into a satisfying whole.
04/27/01
It's grabbing you by the lapels and screaming, 'Laugh!'
04/27/01
Top CriticA clever idea that isn't executed cleverly enough.
04/26/01
The script is tired and airless, desperate to make you laugh, and failing at that.
04/26/01
With its distinctive voice, the irreverent comedy makes the unsavory seem tasty.
04/26/01
An overwritten, overacted, overedited, heck even overorchestrated dark comedy.
04/26/01
Latest News for One Night at McCool's
June 11, 2007:
"Pink Panther" is Coming Back With a New Director
You knew it was coming: Steve Martin in a "Pink Panther" sequel. More...
April 20, 2006:
Critical Consensus: A Weak "Sentinel," So-So "Dreamz" Are Made Of This, "Silent Hill" Not Screened
This week at the movies we've got a Secret Service agent on a mission ("The Sentinel"), an "American Idol"- skewering political satire ("American... More...
What’s Hot On RT
Other News
Fresh Links
Featured
RT on YouTube 
Subscribe to RT's YouTube channel and don't miss a second of our cracking video content.
RT on Twitter
Follow Rotten Tomatoes and join us as we tweet about the week's releases.
IGN RSS Feeds