I'm Reed Fish (2007)
Tomatometer
How does the Tomatometer work 
Reviews Counted:20
Fresh:11
Rotten:9
Average Rating:5.1/10
Runtime: 1 hr 33 mins
Genre: Comedies
Synopsis: This quirky coming-of-age tale stars Jay Baruchel (of television's cult hit UNDECLARED) as a young man in the midst of preparing for a wedding to his longtime girlfriend (Alexis Bledel). But who... [More]
Starring: Jay Baruchel, Alexis Bledel, Schulyer Fisk, Katey Sagal
Director: Zackary Adler
Reviews for I'm Reed Fish
| Tomatometer | Critic | Review | Category |
|---|---|---|---|
 2/5 |
Kid-friendly rom-com lures but doesn't hook. Full Review |
||
 4/5 |
A breezy, wholly engaging ninety minutes spent with a delightful cast. Full Review |
||
|
76/100 |
Standard romantic comedy, but it's done so nicely, and is sufficiently spiced up by an unusual what-am-I-really-watching? storytelling device, that it rises above its genre. Full Review |
||
|
B- |
Evoking a smothering sense of poisonous romantic yearning and horrifying personal inventory results, Fish hits those sharp notes of characterization often, in the middle of a plot that dances around convention perhaps one too many times. Full Review |
||
|
Click to read the article Full Review |
|||
|
3/4 |
Click to read the article Full Review |
||
|
C |
Even if cast differently, this would be a weird film. Full Review |
||
|
|
The relentless quirkiness of the proceedings proves wearisome, and the bizarre structural conceit is not enough to compensate for the overly familiar characterizations and story line. Full Review |
||
|
1/5 |
Perhaps in more experienced hands, this self-reflection could achieve insight, but as director Adler’s first feature and Fish’s first produced screenplay, this mess was better left inside the writer’s head. Full Review |
||
|
|
Charms you with a quirkiness that feels oddly genuine and unforced. Full Review |
||
|
2/5 |
Filled with painfully awkward men with painfully bad haircuts, I'm Reed Fish exhibits less energy than a sloth on Seconal.
|
||
|
2/6 |
Some nice performances (Fisk is especially appealing as Reed’s love interest) and a go-nowhere midfilm meta shift don’t propel the movie beyond its pat life-lesson intentions. Full Review |
||
|
2.5/4 |
Fish's tender evocation of being forced by a life-changing epiphany to find the courage to step outside the confines of routine is beautifully realized by an endearing ensemble. Full Review |
||
|
.5/4 |
The movie, which looks like it was made on the cheapest camera borrowed from the A/V club, was apparently based on the experience of its writer, Reed Fish, who should either await more interesting experiences or work up some imagination. Full Review |
||
|
2.5/4 |
Modest charmer about a folksy community radio show host. Full Review |
||
|
2.5/4 |
The acting is good, the turf is familiar, and the mood is sweet without causing diabetes. Full Review |
||
|
|
Add a bunch of indie bands, find a Braff look-alike (Jay Baruchel) to play the lead, top it off with some obscure animal hybrid -- a zorse instead of a liger -- and you've got writer Reed Fish's can't-fail debut. Full Review |
||
|
1.5/4 |
Sundance homilies and truisms are encased in a meta frame in I'm Reed Fish. Full Review |
||
|
5/10 |
...demonstrates a lot of talent, but it's another case of a neophyte filmmaker not recognizing where his true strengths lie Full Review |
||
|
|
Pic's power lies not in postmodernism but in its take on how rural youths relate to the contemporary scene. Full Review |
CommentLatest News for I'm Reed Fish
September 05, 2007:
RT on DVD: It's TV Time!
It's definitely a week for TV on DVD. With the exception of a few exceptional dramatic feature films (Stephanie Daley, The Wind That Shakes the Barley), today's releases offer a... More...
What’s Hot On RT
Other News
Fresh Links
Featured
Subscribe to RT's YouTube channel and don't miss a second of our cracking video content.
Follow Rotten Tomatoes and join us as we tweet about the week's releases.
IGN RSS Feeds