
Day Seven: Star Trek: Generations
Where to start with this movie? Star Trek: Generations is almost totally impenetrable for much of its running time, before it takes a strange, elegiac turn toward the end. It does little to introduce Picard and the rest of the Next Generation crew, and it requires an absurd amount of insider knowledge. I can't say I liked it, or even understood most of it, though its ending helps to redeem it a little.
Generations was released a few months after Star Trek: The Next Generation had gone off the air. The movie requires a familiarity with the characters -- something I don't have -- and the plot is hopelessly convoluted and uninvolving. Indeed, there were various points during which I stared slack-jawed at the screen and asked aloud, "Who are these people? What is going on?" And then, three-fourths of the way through, Generations becomes a meditation on whether it is best to live in a pleasurable - but illusory - dream world, or take your chances with messy reality.
As the movie begins, Kirk, Scotty, and Chekov are attending the maiden voyage of a brand new Enterprise shortly after the events of The Undiscovered Country. Kirk feels a bit out of place, but puts up an agreeable front. And he's greeted by Sulu's daughter Demora, now a pilot on the ship. "When did he find time for a family?" Kirk asks Scotty. This strikes me as absurd; the Enterprise crew spends all their time together, and yet this bit of information would have just eluded Kirk? Apparently, they don't have Facebook in the 23rd century. (By the way, spare me the "it turns out Sulu was gay!" jokes. Really tired of 'em.)
Anyway, with journalists everywhere and Cameron from Ferris Bueller's Day Off at the helm, the ship pushes off for what's meant to be a glorified galactic press conference, since the Enterprise is understaffed and not fully operational. However, a distress call comes from two ships full of refugees that are trapped in an energy ribbon. Since the Enterprise is the only available ship nearby, it's pressed into duty. (This strikes me as problematic. The ship just left its dock, and there aren't any other crafts nearby?) One of the ships is destroyed, and the Enterprise is able to beam aboard only a fraction of the second ship's populance. However, the Enterprise finds itself stuck in the ribbon, and Kirk volunteers to go into the bowels of the ship to fix its deflector shields, which will facilitate an escape. He's successful, but when crew members go looking for him, he's gone, sucked through a missing portion of the ship. It's a rocky start for the movie, lacking the tension or poignancy it's obviously gunning for.
Then, without fanfare, the film moves ahead 78 years in the future. The Enterprise finds itself up against Soran (Malcolm McDowell), who, along with Guinan (Whoopi Goldberg), was among the refugees saved by the Enterprise 78 years ago. Picard wants to find out more about Soran's plans, so he turns to Guinan, who explains that Soran is attempting to enter the Nexus, a strange nether-region contained within the energy ribbon. Meanwhile, Data (Brett Spiner) an android, decides to implant emotion chip in his brain, to learn what it means to be human -- and the result is a lot of grating laughter and bad one-liners, apparently.
So far, I'm not taken with this crew; the film assumes way too much prior knowledge of them for non-acolytes to find anything to latch on to. Especially grating is Data; I know he's supposed to be a sort of Spock proxy, attempting to understand the human condition, but what's with all his lame affectations? Do Trekkies find him amusing? At least he's memorable; the other cast members are given so little to do that they seem like extras.
The Enterprise runs into the Klingons, who have teamed up with Soran. He has transported to the planet Veridian III, where he's set up a missile system to facilitate his transport into the Nexus. The Enterprise is attacked by a Bird of Prey, which badly damages its systems; though the Klingon ship is destroyed, the Enterprise is sent hurtling toward Veridian III.
As with previous installments, bodies go flying all over the place every time the Enterprise is hit by torpedoes, goes through rough energy patches, etc. However, Generations takes this to an absurd extreme; it seems the entire cast is constantly soaring through the air like extras in Any Given Sunday. (I'm assuming there are no vehicle safety requirements in the Starfleet; where's Ralph Nader when you need him?) Soran detonates a nearby star with a missile; the result is that he and Picard (who has beamed down to the planet) are sucked into the Nexus, but all the nearby planets, including Veridian III, where the Enterprise has crash-landed, have been destroyed.
Just as I'm ready to give up hope, Generations makes an abrupt shift and turns into a poor man's version of Solaris -- which isn't a bad thing at all. Picard awakes to find himself in a stately home, decorated for Christmas. He is greeted warmly by his "children" and his "wife," as well as his nephew. (It was explained earlier that Picard's brother, as well as his wife and family, were killed, and that Picard, who never married himself, has longed for some sort of home life.) He soaks up this yuletide merriment, realizing it's an idealized vision of his lost dreams, but he's uneasy; where is he? Fortunately, a spectral Guinan is on hand to explain that he's entered the Nexus, a place that bends itself to create an idyllic version of an inhabitant's life. Picard asks how he can get out and stop Soran, and Guinan tells him that she can't help - but perhaps Captain Kirk can.
I'll admit it: I was a sucker for this turn of events. After more than an hour of Trek-speak, Data's antics, and not being able to tell the players without a scorecard, it was refreshing to find something to grasp onto. There's a sensorial pleasure to this scene that's been acutely lacking in the film; you can almost smell the fireplace and the Christmas tree, and the Brian Eno-esque ambient soundtrack creates a mood of sad mystery.
Guinan facilitates Picard's transport to Kirk, who's living in a cabin surrounded by mountains. When Picard arrives, he's chopping wood and preparing breakfast (I suspect that a certain subset of Trek fans went into seizures of ecstasy at this historic meeting). At first, Kirk is too caught up in his happy routine to pay Picard much notice, but then he too is unsettled by the strange perfection of his surroundings. Plus, Kirk was never one to play by the rules, or to avoid risk. So he agrees to join Picard. "Who am I to argue with the captain of the Enterprise?" he says.
This sets up a final showdown with Soran, in which the captains put a hurting on their nemesis before setting the missile to self destruct. Soran is killed in the blast, but Kirk too is mortally wounded after sustaining a great fall. His last words, whispered to Picard: "It was... fun."
Yes indeed, Kirk. It was fun, especially when I cared about characters like you. Next up is Star Trek: First Contact; I'm told that resistance to this one is futile. Will it put the franchise back on track? Will I bond with this new Enterprise crew, which so many Trekkies hold in high esteem? I certainly hope so.
Stardates:
- Day One: Star Trek: The Motion Picture (1979)
- Day Two: Star Trek: The Wrath of Khan (1982)
- Day Three: Star Trek III: The Search for Spock (1984)
- Day Four: Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home (1986)
- Day Five: Star Trek V: The Final Frontier (1989)
- Day Six: Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country (1991)
- Day Seven: Star Trek: Generations (1994)
- Day Eight: Star Trek: First Contact (1996)
- Day Nine: Star Trek: Insurrection (1998)
- Day Ten: Star Trek: Nemesis (2002)
- Day Eleven: Star Trek (2009)
|
damvbat writes: on May 01 2009 06:23 PM yea this movie really really sucked (Reply to this) |
|
Stephen L. writes: on May 01 2009 06:31 PM Data is just... he's lovable. (Reply to this) |
|
Alexander E. writes: on May 01 2009 06:33 PM I've never commented before, but I had to speak up this time. I love every write up that Tim has come up with until now. I didn't love this movie, but being a child of the 90's and loving TNG, this movie really did it for me. I recently rewatched it and when the Enterprise is about to crash, Data subtly yells "Oh ****". I almost peed my pants laughing. Can't wait til you tackle First Contact Tim, first time real fear was put into Star Trek. (Reply to this) |
|
frankdozier writes: on May 01 2009 06:38 PM When I watched this movie when it came out, I liked it OK, but then again, I'd seen every episode of STTNG two or three times. It's too bad too, because you're gonna be disappointed with the lack of character development in the next movie as well. That'll be OK though, because First Contact is an action-packed ride, and James Cromwell keeps the laughs comin. (Reply to this) |
|
utkipp1 writes: on May 01 2009 06:42 PM First Contact was the best of the bunch in my opinion. And Picard > Kirk (Reply to this) |
|
Brian H. writes: on May 01 2009 06:45 PM Data's antics probably are confusing to someone who never watched TNG. For fans, it was a long-awaited development in his character that never got resolved in the show... He finally attempted to embrace and use the emotion chip that his creator had made for him - after spending the entire series trying to learn what it was to be human as merely an observer, we finally got to see him try and experience emotion himself. I have to say, that as a TNG and Data fan, that particular arc in the film is one of my favorite things in Generations. Please don't judge Data by his ill reaction to the chip! :) (Reply to this) |
|
Looselycult writes: on May 01 2009 06:53 PM This movies was nothing but a shameless as well as contrived excuse just to get Kirk and Picard in the same shot with one another, and also to make money from suckers like me who payed to see it. I remember when this came out "The Star Gate" was playing in the same theater and my friends wanted to see it instead. I was bummed cause I had heard Kirk and Picard were in it together. I wasn't much of a fan of Next Gen but I liked Picard. Anyway we saw "Star Gate" instead, which now I wish that I had just been satisfied with it instead of going back later to see "Generations" anyway. Man those people can't act themselves out of a paper bag. (Reply to this) |
|
Looselycult writes: on May 01 2009 06:54 PM This movies was nothing but a shameless as well as contrived excuse just to get Kirk and Picard in the same shot with one another, and also to make money from suckers like me who payed to see it. I remember when this came out "The Star Gate" was playing in the same theater and my friends wanted to see it instead. I was bummed cause I had heard Kirk and Picard were in it together. I wasn't much of a fan of Next Gen but I liked Picard. Anyway we saw "Star Gate" instead, which now I wish that I had just been satisfied with it instead of going back later to see "Generations" anyway. Man those people can't act themselves out of a paper bag. (Reply to this) |
|
WallEField writes: on May 01 2009 07:23 PM The Next Generation crew is great...it's just that very few movies really do anything to show them off like the few good TOS movies did for that crew. The only one I recall seeing and liking of TNG movies is First Contact, and even then it assumes prior knowledge of both movies and show, but is still accessible. Also, Data is awesome. (Reply to this) |
|
Ninerfan writes: on May 01 2009 07:29 PM I dont get the love for First Contact. I thought that movie was one of most boring of the bunch to much talking for me and no action. The best were 1)Wrath of Khan 2)The Voyage Home 3)The Undiscoverd Country 4)The Search for Spock 5)Generations I put Voyage Home #2 cause it was pretty funny "double dumb *** on you" (Reply to this) |
|
ledawg1138 writes: on May 01 2009 07:31 PM I like it. 7/10. I had a lot of issues, but in the end I had to admit I liked it. (Reply to this) |
|
ck100 writes: on May 01 2009 08:08 PM This movie is hard for newbies to enjoy especially if they're not familiar with Picard's crew. So I can understand your plight in enjoying this movie since you're a Trek novice. Hopefully you can at least somewhat get to know Picard and his crew better as you go through the next three movies with them. This movie is also clearly a transitional movie so it can be a little difficult to enjoy it. I think if you watched TNG you would have enjoyed the movie more. At least you got some enjoyment out of the movie as it went forward. Anyway, the movie has its faults, but I like it. I consider it a "middle-of-the-road" Trek movie. Not the best the franchise has to offer, but certainly not the worst. Just really in the middle overall. 7/10. As I said, it's clearly a transitional movie from Kirk's crew to Picard's crew. You really have to be familiar with both crews to get the full enjoyment. (Reply to this) |
|
sunsaz writes: on May 01 2009 08:15 PM This was the first ST movie I got to see in theaters, so it gets those points. Other than being the 2nd best TNG film (a DISTANT 2nd I might add), there really isn't much going for this one. (Reply to this) |
|
Donkey P. writes: on May 01 2009 08:43 PM Generations = as bad as a BJ from a girl who uses her teeth. (Reply to this) |
|
vitaboy writes: on May 01 2009 08:52 PM Yeah, Generations sucked. Agree with basically everything you said, Tim! All Trek fans should read this rather enlightening post about Star Trek that turned out to be rather prescient even though it was written in 1999. It pretty much explains why the Next Generation ST movies were so atrocious (the exception being "First Contact," which was just --- ht T The obvious answer is Rick Berman. And maybe it's as simple as that. After all, before signing on with "Trek" at the beginning of the decade, Berman was in charge of Paramount's miniseries division, and he had been responsible for the Emmy-winning children's TV series "The Big Blue Marble." When he first met with Roddenberry in 1986, during his initial talks with Paramount about a new "Trek" series, Berman told the so-called Great Bird of the Galaxy he didn't know one thing about "Star Trek," aside from the one or two episodes he had seen as a kid. If nothing else, Berman was honest. Five years later, Berman found himself in charge of the franchise. Within two years he had alienated Spock and had become one of the men responsible for killing off Captain Kirk in the film "Star Trek: Generations." For longtime fans like me, it's been downhill from there. "The dirty little secret is Berman and the people running 'Star Trek' right now hate 'The Original Series' and hate being compared to it," says Altman, referred to by the Los Angeles Times as the "world's foremost Trekspert." Altman, during his days as a sci-fi magazine journalist, actually used to have a good relationship with Berman until he became critical of "Next Generation" and "Voyager." "They are not people who have any affection for the old show. When [producer] Harve Bennett and [director] Nick Meyer took over the franchise for 'Star Trek II,' they went back and looked at every episode of 'The Original Series' and learned everything they could about what worked and what didn't. When these guys [Berman and writer Brannon Braga] took over, they hated the original and resented being in the shadow and avoided watching it. They'd be happy if people forgot the original, and that's unfortunate." Rick Berman is the anti-Gene." .... Berman's decision to kill Kirk wasn't merely a pragmatic solution to a nonexistent quandary. After all, why couldn't Paramount make films using both casts, at least until the original crew of the Enterprise started dying off in real life? No, his execution of Kirk symbolized a lack of understanding of what made the show so endearing for so long. You can put any group of people in Starfleet uniforms, but if there is no sense of humor, no sense of purpose, no sense of compassion, then it sure as hell ain't "Star Trek." "There has definitely been a difference in vision than what we were doing, and that's either for better or worse," says Nimoy, who says he does not watch the new shows because he hasn't the time. "You have to give them credit, because, on the one hand, we only lasted three seasons and were canceled. They lasted 12 years with three different shows. If you put the aggregate years together, that's like 30 years of 'Star Trek.' And they have a right to call it 'Star Trek,' but it has evolved into something different. What it is, I don't know -- I don't watch enough of it to pass judgment. "I can tell you on a very general level I think we had a certain kind of charm and a currency. I felt we were in touch with the time. Now, times have changed, and maybe it's not as easy to grab hold of a Zeitgeist as it was for us. We were dealing with very strong social movements of the time. By that, I mean the civil rights movement, the Vietnam War, overpopulation concerns, the growing awareness of concerns for the planet. We had very rich, fertile territory to plow, and I think we did it very well. I don't know that these people have the same kind of territory to plow, except, 'How are we going to get home this week?' It's not the same, is it?" Nimoy has never forgiven Berman for the poor handling of Kirk's death -- and for the fact that Braga and Moore, in their original "The Undiscovered Territory" script, had reduced the Spock and McCoy characters to nothing but walk-on parts, another sign of how little these men cared about the original show. Nimoy says he wouldn't have minded so much had he been asked to direct the film before the script was written. Even if the Spock role was to be small, at least as director Nimoy could find some way to give him an identity. "I had directed two very successful 'Star Trek' movies, and 'IV,' it's safe to say, is to this day the most successful," Nimoy says. "But the point is, when I was asked to do them, I was brought in first, as the director to make a movie for Paramount Pictures. When Rick Berman announced to me he had been hired as producer to make the next 'Star Trek' movie, I said to him, 'Who's going to direct it?' And he said, 'Well, it would be very exciting to work with you as a director someday,' which I thought was very evasive. Then several months later, after he and his people had done the script, they called me and said, 'We would love to have you direct this movie.' "Well, this is an entirely different construct than making a movie for Paramount. Now, I'm making a movie for Rick Berman, you see. Well, the script was lousy. I said so: 'This needs major, major work.' They said, 'Well, we don't have time for the kind of changes you're talking about.' So I said goodbye. And then to end it with a fight scene between Kirk and Malcolm McDowell! What's the point?" Since then, Nimoy has not talked to Paramount about anything related to "Star Trek" -- with one exception: He and business partner John de Lancie (better known as "Next Generation's" Q) have shipped to stores this week an hour-long audio version of their "Spock vs. Q" two-man show, which they've performed at a half-dozen "Star Trek" conventions. Nimoy licenses the character from Paramount; that's the extent of his relationship with the studio. "Which is a shame," Nimoy says, "since Rick Berman and I used to be ---- (Reply to this) |
|
rico r. writes: on May 01 2009 09:07 PM Yeah...I think the thing is about familiarity. This is far from one of my favorite films in the canon, and poor you, Star Trek movies finally preach only to the choir. TNG crew/cast really IS fantastic (thought I agree Data takes a turn for the worst in the films with the "emotion chip." Not a development I'm fond of). If you're interested, I recommend a handful of episodes from the show that may (or no) change your mind, or at least fill some gaps. Try: "The Measure of a Man" from season 2 "The Best of Both Worlds (pts 1 & 2)" the season 3 cliffhanger "First Contact" from season 4 - and no relation to the next movie "The Inner Light" from season 5 AND, if you're really ambitious, try the pilot, "Encounter at Farpoint" followed immediately by the series finale, "All Good Things..." They are connected. You may end up liking these folk some. (Reply to this) |
|
niall1 writes: on May 01 2009 09:29 PM yah this one was kind of made for trekkies only, but the next one is fantastic, its one of my favourite films ever.. (Reply to this) |
|
Daniel L. writes: on May 01 2009 09:30 PM Tim, it's too bad that Generations is your first introduction to the Next Gen crew since you're right, this movie assumes that you already know and care about the crew. They are a very good ensemble cast, but this movie comes after 7 years of 20 episode seasons, that's a LOT of story- this movie was basically designed to be the series' "finale" of storts, since they started filming it immediately after the series wrapped without a "real" finale. Data's antics, for example, are a TERRIBLE way for you to firs meet his character, since it would be like your first experience of spock being a time when he's under a mind-altering drug and laughing or being emotional or something- Data was, until this point in the series, entirely incapable of emotion, so seeing him discover emotion for the very first time in this movie was much more interesting for veterins than for the un-initiated. AS for First Contact, I think you'll like it more since it's more action-y and accessible. It's as close to horror as star trek ever gets, and I think they did a good job. It still isn't a good way to introduce the next gen crew- I'm afraid there's really no way to fall in love with the next-gen crew without actually watching at least a portion of the series itself, since none of the next-gen movies were ever really meant to cater to anyone but star trek fans. (Reply to this) |
|
ARTaylor writes: on May 01 2009 09:46 PM I love every moment in this movie and love watching it over and over again. But then again I think TNG is the greatest series ever and have practically memorized every episode. I put this one on the same level as Search for Spock, it's great for Trekkies but normies may not get it. But I think it's very underrated among Trekkies. How can anyone not be on the edge of their seat when the Ent-D saucer goes down? And I think it was so much better than the original's destruction. Unlike the original, it was still top of the line and as they say shouldn't have been destroyed by the old bird of prey. Completely out of left field. I can't think of any better way to get Kirk and Picard together. I always thought that "Don't let them promote you" scene was a great passing of the torch. And the scene in the cabin was perfect Kirk and Picard. Solid B grade. (Reply to this) |
|
BatsInTheBelfry writes: on May 01 2009 10:16 PM I like Generations okay, I certainly think it's the best of the odd numbered films. However, the last episode of Star Trek: TNG is better than all of the movies. It is still the best final episode of any show in the history of television, in my opinion. (Reply to this) |
| You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register. |









