Ebert & Roeper: "V For Vendetta" Dark, Thoughtful, And That's Good
On their weekly syndicated show "Ebert & Roeper," Roger Ebert and Richard Roeper gave early reviews of "V For Vendetta" -- and gave the comic adaptation two thumbs up.
Ebert enjoyed the revolutionary superhero tale of a lone freedom fighter in a fascist future Britain, despite not being able to draw specific analogies between the film's political message and any corresponding situations in the real world: "The strange thing is I kept feeling it was a sharply pointed political parable but I couldn't get the parallel going." Despite this apparent ambiguity, Ebert said "it does make incoherence really entertaining."
Equally impressed, Roeper commended the overall performances of Hugo Weaving and Natalie Portman -- "she kind of wrestled with her English accent here and there, but it's a nice performance" -- and dismissed the controversy that "Vendetta" glorifies terrorism, noting that anarchist hero V is labeled a terrorist "by someone who's essentially Hitler, a dictator."
Both Ebert and Roeper drew the quite obvious thematic parallels to "Phantom of the Opera" (V's masked mentor), "1984" (with John Hurt as Big Brother), and even "Beauty and the Beast" (guess which is which). Both critics were also quite taken with the film.
Ebert celebrated the growing maturity of comic book adaptations, which "are getting more thoughtful and challenging in their stories and after "Batman Begins" and "Spiderman 2", "V For Vendetta" is one of the most intriguing so far."
Roeper agreed: "There are some great brilliant action scenes but this is more thoughtful, darker, and more in the vein of "Batman Begins." And that's a very good thing."
For Ebert & Roeper's complete audio review, visit their official site.
"V For Vendetta" comes out this Friday, March 17. Incidentally, it now has a Tomatometer of 77%, with 13 reviews.

Ebert enjoyed the revolutionary superhero tale of a lone freedom fighter in a fascist future Britain, despite not being able to draw specific analogies between the film's political message and any corresponding situations in the real world: "The strange thing is I kept feeling it was a sharply pointed political parable but I couldn't get the parallel going." Despite this apparent ambiguity, Ebert said "it does make incoherence really entertaining."
Equally impressed, Roeper commended the overall performances of Hugo Weaving and Natalie Portman -- "she kind of wrestled with her English accent here and there, but it's a nice performance" -- and dismissed the controversy that "Vendetta" glorifies terrorism, noting that anarchist hero V is labeled a terrorist "by someone who's essentially Hitler, a dictator."
Both Ebert and Roeper drew the quite obvious thematic parallels to "Phantom of the Opera" (V's masked mentor), "1984" (with John Hurt as Big Brother), and even "Beauty and the Beast" (guess which is which). Both critics were also quite taken with the film.
Ebert celebrated the growing maturity of comic book adaptations, which "are getting more thoughtful and challenging in their stories and after "Batman Begins" and "Spiderman 2", "V For Vendetta" is one of the most intriguing so far."
Roeper agreed: "There are some great brilliant action scenes but this is more thoughtful, darker, and more in the vein of "Batman Begins." And that's a very good thing."
For Ebert & Roeper's complete audio review, visit their official site.
"V For Vendetta" comes out this Friday, March 17. Incidentally, it now has a Tomatometer of 77%, with 13 reviews.

Related Items
| Celeb: | Roger Ebert |
| Natalie Portman | |
| Hugo Weaving | |
| Movie: | Batman Begins |
| Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera | |
| Spider-Man 2 | |
| V For Vendetta | |
| Beauty and the Beast | |
| 1984 | |
| Critic: | Richard Roeper |
|
on Mar 13 2006 02:41 PM So begins the golden age of comic book movies... This and Superman are going to make this a good year. I just hope X-men 3 doesn't bring the train to a stop. (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 13 2006 03:46 PM [b]I cant wait[/b] now if only videogames would be taken seriously we might be able to get a couple good movies out of them as well. (Reply to this) |
![]() on Mar 13 2006 05:38 PM In reply to this comment (#832067) ditto (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 13 2006 06:29 PM [b]Rolling Stone[/b] RS gave "V" 3 & 1/2 stars. So far so good. (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 13 2006 06:46 PM Things are looking up. Maybe it's time for Alan Moore to come back out of the woodwork and grudgingly acknowledge his relationship with this film. (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 13 2006 07:50 PM In reply to this comment (#832066) [b]X3[/b] The trailers are very promising - don't write off X3 just yet. And if it weren't for the fact that Singer is helming "Superman Returns," I'd be very suspicious. It has the potential for cheese written all over it - just the sight of Kevin Spacey in a bald cap is enough to worry me... (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 13 2006 09:05 PM I'm hopin' Halo turns out to be amazing, maybe that will be how the videogame movies get rolling. Anywho, took off work Friday to meet up with people and see V so, it better be good!! (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 13 2006 11:38 PM yes please halo! god microsoft , bungie and whoever is taking charge of this film dont let us down! as for V i knew it was going to get good reviews. the wachowskis are good man, real good. cant wait! (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 14 2006 03:35 AM V is the shining hope for me, it may restore my faith in Hollywood. And as for video game adaptations, Silent Hill looks really good, at least the trailer does (Reply to this) |
|
on Mar 15 2006 01:24 PM This is definitely good news, it just keeps sounding better. (Reply to this) |
Related Links
Related Articles
- Ebert Meets the Wachowskis
3 - Watch Ebert & Roeper's Final Review
12 - An Oral History of RT, Part One: The Beginning 11
- Roger Ebert Gets Back to Work 35
- Peter Berg Confirmed to Direct New Dune Film 74
- Meet a Critic: Roger Ebert! 79
- Forbes Pundit List Gives Thumbs Up to Ebert 13
- Disney Declared "Thumbs" Ban, Ebert Says 36
- The Return of Roger Ebert 32
- Roger Ebert Writes, Reviews and Recovers 10
Most Discussed
- Five Favorite Films with Paris Hilton 124
- The Net Reacts to 25 Minutes of Watchmen Footage 49
- Weekly Ketchup: Branagh directs Thor, Seagal vs. aliens? 45
- Critics Consensus: Chihuahua a Dog; Nick and Norah a Hot Item 43
- Box Office Guru Wrapup: Chihuahua is Top Dog 33
- Total Recall: The 15 Greatest Paul Newman Movies 23
- Box Office Guru Preview: Chihuahua to Overtake Multiplexes 18
- Exclusive: The Fall - Tarsem's Visual Companion - Part 1 12
- RT on DVD: The Future of Watchmen, Plus Sleeping Beauty, Touch of Evil Remastered 5
- Further Reading: Marion Cotillard and Forest Whittaker in Abel Ferrara's Mary 3
Latest News
- RT on DVD: The Future of Watchmen, Plus Sleeping Beauty, Touch of Evil Remastered 5
- Exclusive: The Fall - Tarsem's Visual Companion - Part 2 2
- Box Office Guru Wrapup: Chihuahua is Top Dog 33
- Weekly Ketchup: Branagh directs Thor, Seagal vs. aliens? 45
- Exclusive: The Fall - Tarsem's Visual Companion - Part 1 12
- UK Critics Consensus: How To Lose Friends & Alienate People Does Just That; Whilst Brideshead Revisited Is Resisted 1
- Further Reading: Marion Cotillard and Forest Whittaker in Abel Ferrara's Mary 3
- Critics Consensus: Chihuahua a Dog; Nick and Norah a Hot Item 43
- Box Office Guru Preview: Chihuahua to Overtake Multiplexes 18
- The Net Reacts to 25 Minutes of Watchmen Footage 49
Latest Interviews
- RT Interview: Jason Statham Chats Death Race, Crank 2 and The Sweeney 9
- Video Exclusive: Gerard Butler talks RocknRolla and 300 sequel with RT 13
- Video Exclusive: Maria Bello, Brendan Fraser and the Mummy 3 Cast Talk to RT 14
- RT goes behind the scenes on Stargate: Continuum 4
- Starship Troopers' Casper Van Dien Shares His Five Favorite Films 48
- RT Interview: Philippe Petit on Crossing the Twin Towers on a Wire 2
- RT Interview: David Duchovny on The X-Files, Californication and Directing 11
- RT Interview: Ben Barnes on Taking on the Journey of Prince Caspian 1
- RT Interview: William Moseley on His Last Narnia Adventure in Prince Caspian 2
- RT Interview: Jack Black on Kung Fu Panda 6
Latest Features
- Exclusive: The Fall - Tarsem's Visual Companion - Part 2 2
- Exclusive: The Fall - Tarsem's Visual Companion - Part 1 12
- Five Favorite Films with Paris Hilton 124
- Exclusive: Brand New The Children Photos and Director Introduction 5
- Five Favorite Films with Chuck Palahniuk 38
- Five Favorite Films with Dane Cook 103
- Five Favorite Films with Eva Mendes 51
- What The Hell Happened To ... Cuba Gooding Jr.? 86
- RT's Summer in Review: The Best, The Worst, and Our Favorite Films! 77
- What The Hell Happened To Shannon Elizabeth? 101

