IGN.com|AskMen.com|Rotten Tomatoes|GameSpy|FilePlanet|TeamXbox|CheatsCodesGuides|GameStats|Direct2Drive
RottenTomatoes.com
Register | Log In | What is RT?
Home Movies DVD Celebrities News Critics Trailers & Pictures The Vine Forums
Features | Columns | Guides
RT Search Powered by Google
help icon Enhanced RT
searches on Google
Click here to turn on enhanced search results from RT on your Google searches by subscribing to our Google Subscribed Links profile.
 
news
TORONTO: Zhang Ziyi, Yuen Woo-Ping's Latest "Banquet" Not Very Fulfilling
by Senh Duong | September 13, 2006
Blog Article | Discuss Article
Zhang Ziyi and action director Yuen Woo-Ping last worked together in "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon," a movie which helped change audience perception that martial arts movies can be artful and open the door for similar movies such as "Hero" and "House of Flying Daggers." Their latest collaboration, "The Banquet," looks just as good as "Crouching Tiger," but the film is undermined by a story element that's over-used in recent wuxia epics from China. More on that later.

Let's start with the craftsmanship on "The Banquet." It's impeccable. I give the people who worked on the visuals an A, maybe even an A+. You will not find a single frame in this film that wouldn't make a great wallpaper. The costumes and sets, which are meticulously designed, look amazing. The locations are appropriately picturesque. The two lead actresses even become part of the eye candy. Some of the cinematography look like it came straight from "Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon." The effects work, mostly used to show off the grandness of the palace, is solid for a Chinese production.

Now here's my major beef with the movie - "Banquet" is another wuxia epic with a love triangle. There's one in "Hero," "House of Flying Daggers," "Seven Swords," and "The Promise." That said, of the bunch, including "The Banquet," "Hero" is most successful in its usage. But enough is enough already. Doesn't China have any other types of stories to tell? China shouldn't be banning directors like Lou Ye from making controversial films; it should be banning the love triangle from the wuxia genre. Please, no more. The story, about one woman's ascension to the top of the imperial ladder, is straight-forward enough and easy to follow, but there's really not enough here for a feature length film.

There's also not a single sympathetic character in the film. We're supposed to be rooting for the late Emperor's son Wu Luan (Dan Wu) to avenge his father's death and become the rightful ruler, but he spends most of his time brooding. I'm not sure if Empress Wan (Zhang Ziyi) is sleeping her way to the top out of pure ambition or out of necessity or both. Either way, it's difficult to sympathize with an Empress who secretly lusts for her step-son. The Grand Marshall's family is pretty dysfunctional as well. The brother lusts after his sister, who is in love with Wu Luan. It's all very incestuous. I don't have any problems keeping up with who's lusting after whom, but the movie doesn't make me want to care about any part of it.

For a film in which the action is directed by legendary fight choreographer Yuen Woo-Ping, the fight scenes are pretty tepid and unimaginative. Zhang Ziyi doesn't have a single fight scene. She spends most of her screen time in lavish costumes.

In summary, “The Banquet” is a visually stunning film, but I wish the visual elements are employed in the service of a better story. That's pretty much what other critics are saying too. Variety's Derek Elley thinks the "main problem is Zhang, who carries herself with all the bearing of a power-hungry, lovelorn empress but doesn't project the necessary charisma of an evil queen." The Hollywood Reporter's Kirk Honeycutt says "The Banquet" wastes its "astonishing" and "strikingly beautiful" production "with a cliched, long-winded, logic-busting, overacted film that at times seems like a parody of the martial arts genre." Screen Daily's Dan Fainaru thinks it's "way too long for its own good, and may prove quick-lived at box offices after initial attention."

"The Banquet" is directed by Feng Xiaogang, China's most commercially successful director. He helmed "A World Without Thieves" (Andy Lau) and "Cell Phone," both blockbusters in China.

Related Items
Movie: Toronto International Film Festival 2006
A World Without Thieves
The Promise
Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
Seven Swords
Hero
House of Flying Daggers
Celeb: Feng Xiaogang
Ziyi Zhang
Ye Lou
Daniel Wu
Yuen Woo-ping
Andy Lau
Bookmark and Share
Comments (1-2 of 2 posts) | Reply
RT-SmellyCat
RT-SmellyCat writes:
on Sep 14 2006 02:32 AM

Feng Xiaogang is currently mainland China's most solid director when it comes to story-telling so I'm kind of surprised that the story turns out to be the weakest part of the movie. This is his first big, sweeping costume epic so maybe he got carried away by the scale of the project. To be honest, I find Zhang Ziyi to be a pretty weak actress and definitely miscast to play the domineering Lady Macbeth/Gertrude-like role -- nonetheless, she definitely can help bring in the B.O. throughout Asia. In terms of unlikeable characters, this would be a problem shared by Hamlet (which The Banquet is supposed to be lightly based off of) as well -- but in the case of Hamlet, even though you don't particularly like him, there's enough humor to offset the soul-searching existenstialism. I've heard that there's not a single laugh throughout The Banquet.

(Reply to this)
Senh Duong writes:
on Sep 14 2006 04:49 AM

In reply to this comment (#844229)
Yeah, the film's pretty serious. On a technical level, it's pretty well made. It just has a lame story.

(Reply to this)
Read More Comments
Page | 1
Post Your Comment
You must be registered to post comments. Login or Register.
Related Links
The Banquet
  • Pictures
  • Posters
  • News
  • Forum
Related Articles
  • Toronto Wrapup: Senh, Jen And Tim's Raves And Rants From The Festival 15
  • TORONTO: Zhang Ziyi, Yuen Woo-Ping's Latest "Banquet" Not Very Fulfilling 2
  • TORONTO: Blog Day 1 -- "Barley," "Banquet," and the Opening Night Gala! 4
Most Discussed
  • RT's Summer in Review: The Best, The Worst, and Our Favorite Films! 73
  • Exclusive: Zack and Miri Make a Porno Red Band Trailer! 48
  • Weekly Ketchup: J.J. Abrams' Star Trek plot revealed 43
  • Box Office Guru Wrapup: Tropic Thunder Triumphantly closes Summer 35
  • RT on DVD: Transformers Hit Blu-ray; Watch Office DVD Blooper Reel 21
  • Total Recall: RT's Schoolhouse Favorites 21
  • Critics Consensus: Bangkok Dangerous Plays Too Safe 20
  • What The Hell Happened To ... Cuba Gooding Jr.? 19
  • Weekly Ketchup: Raimi and Maguire return for Spider-Man 4 and 5 19
  • RT Steps Up Its Game 15
Latest News
  • Weekly Ketchup: Raimi and Maguire return for Spider-Man 4 and 5 19
  • What The Hell Happened To ... Cuba Gooding Jr.? 19
  • UK Critics Consensus: Rocknrolla Rocks, Disaster Movie = Movie Disaster 0
  • Video Exclusive: Gerard Butler talks RocknRolla and 300 sequel with RT 5
  • Box Office Guru Preview: Cage Offers One Night in Bangkok 11
  • Critics Consensus: Bangkok Dangerous Plays Too Safe 20
  • RT Steps Up Its Game 15
  • RT Exclusive: Ping Pong Playa featurette! 6
  • Total Recall: RT's Schoolhouse Favorites 21
  • Exclusive Stills: Julianne Moore in Blindness 11
Latest Interviews
  • Video Exclusive: Gerard Butler talks RocknRolla and 300 sequel with RT 5
  • Video Exclusive: Maria Bello, Brendan Fraser and the Mummy 3 Cast Talk to RT 14
  • RT goes behind the scenes on Stargate: Continuum 4
  • Starship Troopers' Casper Van Dien Shares His Five Favorite Films 48
  • RT Interview: Philippe Petit on Crossing the Twin Towers on a Wire 2
  • RT Interview: David Duchovny on The X-Files, Californication and Directing 11
  • RT Interview: Ben Barnes on Taking on the Journey of Prince Caspian 1
  • RT Interview: William Moseley on His Last Narnia Adventure in Prince Caspian 2
  • RT Interview: Jack Black on Kung Fu Panda 6
  • RT Interview: Skandar Keynes on the Action Challenge of Prince Caspian 2
Latest Features
  • RT's Summer in Review: The Best, The Worst, and Our Favorite Films! 73
  • What The Hell Happened To Shannon Elizabeth? 96
  • RT Counts Down the Best-Reviewed Theater Movies of all Time! 0
  • Exclusive: Sneak Peek at Coraline! (Video #5) 23
  • What The Hell Happened To Wesley Snipes? 100
  • 20 CGI Classics - From T2 to Batman Begins to WALL-E 163
  • RT's Trailer Analysis: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince 103
  • Kim Newman's Guide to The X-Files 13
  • Picture Show: The Best Costumes of Comic-Con 2008 33
  • Watching the Watchmen Trailer: A Detailed Analysis 108


 
 
About| Site Map| Help| RT To Go| Contact Us| Critics Submission| Linking to RT| Licensing| Movie List| Celebs List| Newsletter

IGN.com | GameSpy | Comrade | Arena | FilePlanet | ModCenter | GameSpy Technology
TeamXbox | Planets | Vaults | VE3D | CheatsCodesGuides | GameStats | GamerMetrics
AskMen.com | Rotten Tomatoes | Direct2Drive


By continuing past this page, and by the continued use of this site, you agree to be bound by and abide by the User Agreement.
Copyright 1998-2008, IGN Entertainment, Inc. About IGN | Support | Advertise | Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Subscribe to RT's XML feed! IGN RSS Feeds
IGN's enterprise databases running Oracle, SQL and MySQL are professionally monitored and managed by Pythian Remote DBA
Certain product data ©1995-present Muze, Inc. For personal use only. All rights reserved.